Thursday, March 07, 2013

[Samurai] Rebooting the Scale?

When I started this blog waaaaaay back in 2006, one of the first things I wrote about was my burgeoning interest in getting into Sengoku-era samurai battles as a new genre of historical miniatures wargaming. Due to a combination of factors, this project did not pan out as planned. It was only last year that I actually managed to get some painted samurai armies on the table, and even then it was in a much-reduced, DBA-ized capacity from my original grandiose schemes.

A major contributing factor in the failure of these schemes was the difficulty I encountered in historical research and finding a ruleset I liked. Yet, going over old entries, I've realized that those problems were addressed and solved over time. The other factor at play was, unfortunately, less easily resolved: my choice of figure scale. Initially, I thought 10mm would be a good choice, as I pictured ranks of colorful banners and sashimonos advancing across the field of battle. But what I came to realize is that it's as much about the lacquered armor and detailed, colorful fabric prints when it comes to the aesthetic appeal of samurai, and that 10mm was too small to fully appreciate the elaborate panoplies donned by the Japanese warriors of the 16th century.

I've been aware of the Perry 28mm samurai and other ranges for some time now, but I've never really considered making the switch to a different scale. I've got  easily hundreds of 10mm figures (that picture's just a portion of my whole collection), even if only about 10 percent of their number are painted and mounted, plus some buildings and rice paddy terrain. So what's a hobbyist to do? Sell off the collection and use the money to switch scales?

Figures painted by the Lonely Gamers' own Leroy Simpson.
Don't mind if I do.

As I wrote in my last entry, I'm in the process of fully embracing my love of 28mm, and a switch away from 10mm is certainly part of that. This daring scheme has the additional advantage of my chosen ruleset, Flagship Games' Taiko!, offering a 1:1 skirmish variant of their 1:50 scale "army" rules, so it will be possible to have games even as the collection is built up and developed for grander engagements.

The downside is that, in selling my 10mm collection to fund my new purchases, I have no idea how much money I can expect to generate. As I've said before, 10mm samurai are a niche of a niche of a niche. I would need to de-mount the unpainted figures that I've got on bases, then count 'em all up, then figure out a reasonable pennies-on-the-dollar amount to charge (and what to charge for the figures that are painted and mounted), then cross my fingers and hope for the best on eBay. That's a lot of work, and so this planned switch will, realistically, remain a pipe dream for the time being.

Unless someone just wants to take the whole collection off my hands for a flat offer. My Google+ contact info's over in the sidebar if you're inclined to talk about an exchange...

EDIT: A reader has done just that and taken the collection off my hands for an agreeable sum! So it looks like that's the final chapter on my star-crossed 10mm samurai. On to Samurai 2.0, then.


  1. Trying to reach you about your 10 mm miniatures, google plus is not intuitive.

  2. I added you to my circles on G+; you should be able to see my email address or post to my wall now. Let me know if you have any problems.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...